Smut & Romance Tropes 101
Updated: Oct 29
The Bothered Blog by Meg Casebolt and Nikki McKnight
October 2026

What is a romance trope and why do readers love them? On this episode of Smut Talks, Allison Whaley talks with Meg Casebolt and Nikki McKnight of First Dates and Soulmates about the language of romance, the evolution of the genre, and the psychology behind our favorite tropes. Plus they explore how familiar storylines can deliver surprising emotional depth—and why sometimes predictability is exactly what we want.
What Is a Trope, Anyway?
Allison: I want this to be an introduction to tropes for anyone who's new to romance, but also a deep dive for people who already love the genre. Let's start simple. What is a trope?
Meg: The definition of a trope is a premise. It's an idea. I like to think of it as when you're looking for something specific in a book, that's the thing that you type into the search bar. Vampire romance is a trope. Small town romance is a trope.
Nikki: The way that I think about tropes are the tags that people used on fanfic back in the day. It's PWP (plot what plot), it's AU (alternate universe), it is friends to lovers, it's enemies to lovers.
One of the reasons I think romance gets criticized a lot is people assume it’s predictable. But as readers, we're like, yeah, that's the promise of the premise, and it's fucking great. It’s an easy way to understand that the romance is going to have a happy ending.
But before the ending? That’s where the fun comes in: what we’ll experience on our way to that happy ending. How is this one particular author, this one particular work going to play with that trope? Who's going to mess with it? It's really funny to see how it's evolved.
Meg: And you can stack these tropes. The interesting thing that authors can do is, how are you stacking tropes that are unexpected, or how are you subverting them and doing something different with them? It's like puzzle pieces, or Legos. If each trope is a Lego and you're building a house with it, then you can take all of these different ideas and put them together.
Nikki: And we’re all up on the shorthand, so the tropes form a large foundation for the community that is built around romance.
Is ‘Tropey’ an Insult?
Allison: Before I got into romance, I actually thought the word trope carried a negative connotation. You hear the phrase "tired trope." Does it deserve that reputation?
Nikki: When romance went more mainstream in the 80s and 90s tropes became a shorthand for lack of creativity and a lack of diversity in storytelling. Whereas now I think tropes allow us to go deeper within a structure and a framework. Now we know that the reader or the audience and I are speaking a similar language, that when I say grumpy sunshine, you know what I mean. But you know what? I'm gonna fuck with you, cause this time the grumpy one is the small twinky-looking one, and the sunshiny is the big dude, and they have depth.
Meg: Now with indie publishing being so popular, a lot of those books that were incredibly popular in the '80s and '90s are seeing a strong decline. Historicals were everywhere through the early aughts. And now we're seeing a huge dip in historicals, and we're seeing a rise in more paranormal, more dark, more monsters, more things that traditional publishing just would not touch—until indie proved that people actually wanted it.
And so those tropes that were like, "Oh, look, it's another small town bakery. Oh no, the bakery's going under, and the only person who can save it is the consultant who comes in from the big city.” It was tropey. And tropey at that point meant predictable and boring, and there was nothing new in that. And now tropes are just a language versus a degradation. The romance community took back the term.
Four Ways to Think About Romance Tropes
Allison: Meg, you have a new framework for looking at tropes. Can you tell us about the bucket categories as you see them?
Meg: I’ve put tropes into 4 different categories:
Situational or relationship style tropes: this is the premise of the main characters, so that would be enemies to lovers, friends to lovers and second chance.
Archetypes: this is who are the main characters and what are their personalities. That would be a vampire, or a jock, or a himbo, or a black cat golden retriever, or grumpy sunshine.
Identity: this is how the main characters identify, so that’s often sexual orientation, sexual identity, poly relationships, bi awakenings, queer awakenings, or asexual.
Setting: that's small town, or holiday, or on vacation. It can also be where is this happening, and how are you engaging with your environment or time? So that’s also forced proximity.
Second Chance Romance: Why Should This Time Be Different?
Allison: Let's start with relational tropes, because a lot of people are familiar with those. Tell me about second chance romance. What makes it psychologically interesting? When a book does this well, why are we hooked?
Meg: Second chance is one of my favorites because it really needs to have multiple different components for it to work. You need to have a history that happened before the book began. And then there needs to be a rupture, where the couple breaks up, and it hurts both of them.
Then you need to see how their lives have changed or been negatively impacted by the fact that they had this rupture. And then when they do get back together, there's a collision of some kind. There's a reckoning stage where they're going, "Oh, you said this! No, you said this!" Or sometimes it's like, "Oh, someone else did this to us." And they have to do some sort of reckoning.
And then finally, there's an agreement of, "Let's try again, and here's how we're different people who are going to behave in a different way, so that we can make it."
Nikki: Second chance romance is built around the question, Why is this time going to be different? And I think this appeals to so many people because how many times have you thought in your life, “I wish I could have gone back and done that differently?”
You might not have had a relationship where forces combined to keep you apart, but I bet you've wished for a second chance at something. And when you put that in a romance where you know it's going to have a happy ending, how fulfilling must that be emotionally and mentally?
Plus, now you get it with good-looking people and sex, which. . . also a win.
Enemies to Lovers: Banter, Tension, and Empathy
Allison: Enemies to lovers is fascinating from both a psychological and a craft perspective. What makes it work?
Nikki: Enemies to lovers is one of my favorites, because I like banter, and I like tension. Plus, it still hits on that character arc. Something has to change, there has to be a realization that maybe they're not that bad, maybe I misunderstood them, maybe there's a reason why they are the way they are.
At the end of the day, it's really about empathy and being able to reconcile what you see or understand about another person for what they truly are, or who they get to become. And that is the satisfying feeling we get at the end, other than, you know, all of the tingles and the groiny bits that typically come from an enemies-to-lovers tension.
Friends to Lovers: The Risk of Ruining a Good Thing
Allison: With friends to lovers, the characters already have a relationship. They love each other, they have kinship. So how do you make readers root for them to become lovers?
Meg: The core of friends to lovers is: if we take the step to turn this relationship from platonic into romantic, we are risking the friendship. There's a gamble.
The friendship has to be so valuable to both sides of it that they don't know if they're willing to take the risk. And then the risk has to rise. Maybe they are going and dating other people, and for the first time they feel that jealousy of "Oh, wait, but I don't like seeing my friend with that person. Why?"
Nikki: This trope really offers an interesting overlap between comfort and tension. There's the comfort because you know this person. You know what they eat, you know what their political values are, you know who their family is. But then you start adding in this new aspect of the relationship and that comfort gets this undercurrent to it.
It's like, "Okay, I know how they order their burger, but I don't know what it's like to kiss them. I don't know what they're like in bed. Do they take care of their partner?" And that becomes the thing that creates tension and curiosity.
Monster Romance: When the “Other” Becomes Familiar
Allison: I've read a lot of monster and alien romances, and I've always thought people read them out of morbid curiosity. What would it be like to have sex with an alien? But I think there's something deeper, really important and common happening here, too. What do these nonhuman characters offer readers?
Nikki: For me, I like romance that’s space, monster, vampire, paranormal, anything that's non-human, because I don't have to relate to any of it. I don't have to see my experience–or my body–on the page.
In a world where the not normal is normal, my brain gets immediate permission to disconnect. To leave stress and anxiety behind, and enjoy it for what it is. Which is just fun.
No self-insertion, and that’s liberating.
We talked about this a little bit in our space romance episode. Why is space romance so appealing? It’s like, if you’re a marginalized identity and you encounter an alien culture and that culture doesn’t care who you sleep with—hey, we sleep with everyone—you get to imagine a world where the things that you experience as hardships just don’t exist. And there’s comfort in that.
Monster romance gives us the ability to approach or interact with the monstrous, the unknown and still see them for who they are. Those character types or settings allow us to wrestle with the hard shit. And realize that monsters or aliens are just living beings.
I think the empathy through-line is a huge player in monster and space romance. And also what can you get from aliens that you can’t get on earth. Interesting.
Meg: And the answer is penis spurs.
---
About the Authors
Meg Casebolt writes romance novels under the pen name Bailey Seaborn. By day she runs Love at First Search, where she works as an AI discoverability strategist for small businesses. She brings the craft lens: story structure, trope mechanics and a forensic interest in why some tropes land and others don't. She built a seven-part fake dating framework while waiting in line at Disneyland. This is just how her brain works.
Nikki McKnight reads over 800 romance novels a year. By day she's an operations strategist. By night she's a gamer, a queer romance devotee and a walking encyclopedia of pop culture connections. She will also tell you, calmly and with citations, when a film has failed its female characters.



Comments